New York Court Upholds Voter Integrity, Bans Noncitizens Voting
Submitted by MAGA
Posted 15 hours ago
New York's highest court has delivered a much-needed victory for election integrity by striking down a controversial law allowing noncitizens to vote in municipal elections in New York City.
In a decisive 6-1 ruling, the New York Court of Appeals affirmed that the state's constitution clearly restricts voting rights to U.S. citizens. Chief Judge Rowan Wilson emphasized the importance of this constitutional boundary in ensuring that voting remains a privilege reserved for those who have pledged allegiance to the United States.
“This ruling is a win for voters and a reaffirmation of the principle that only citizens should have a say in our elections," noted Staten Island Borough President Vito Fossella, a leading advocate against the noncitizen voting law.
The New York City Council had enacted the law in 2021, aiming to extend voting rights to over 800,000 noncitizens living in the city, including green card holders and individuals with work permits. Republicans argued that such measures would dilute the votes of lawful citizens and open the door to potential voter fraud.
After two lower courts ruled against the law, the City Council appealed, attempting to overturn the rulings and implement a policy that many viewed as a threat to the sanctity of the voting process. Critics contend that allowing noncitizens to vote could lead to a slippery slope where municipal governments bypass constitutional restrictions.
Supporters of the law expressed disappointment in the ruling, with some civil rights advocates arguing that noncitizens contribute significantly to the community and should have representation. Yet, this perspective is met with skepticism by many who argue that if anyone outside the citizenship framework is allowed to vote, it undermines the very foundation of democracy.
The dissenting judge, Jenny Rivera, contended that localities should have the authority to structure their voting regulations. However, the overwhelming majority of the court made it clear that state law must prevail.
This ruling sends a strong message that New York will not compromise on the principle that only citizens should vote, reinforcing a critical aspect of American democracy.
As concerns over election integrity continue to mount in a divided political landscape, this decision offers a significant step toward ensuring that every vote cast is genuinely representative of the citizens who earn that right through their allegiance to the United States.
Republicans across the state are hopeful that this win will bolster their efforts to uphold voter integrity and challenge similar laws that seek to expand voting rights to noncitizens in other jurisdictions.
Sources:
gothamist.com
courthousenews.com
trendingpoliticsnews.com
In a decisive 6-1 ruling, the New York Court of Appeals affirmed that the state's constitution clearly restricts voting rights to U.S. citizens. Chief Judge Rowan Wilson emphasized the importance of this constitutional boundary in ensuring that voting remains a privilege reserved for those who have pledged allegiance to the United States.
“This ruling is a win for voters and a reaffirmation of the principle that only citizens should have a say in our elections," noted Staten Island Borough President Vito Fossella, a leading advocate against the noncitizen voting law.
The New York City Council had enacted the law in 2021, aiming to extend voting rights to over 800,000 noncitizens living in the city, including green card holders and individuals with work permits. Republicans argued that such measures would dilute the votes of lawful citizens and open the door to potential voter fraud.
After two lower courts ruled against the law, the City Council appealed, attempting to overturn the rulings and implement a policy that many viewed as a threat to the sanctity of the voting process. Critics contend that allowing noncitizens to vote could lead to a slippery slope where municipal governments bypass constitutional restrictions.
Supporters of the law expressed disappointment in the ruling, with some civil rights advocates arguing that noncitizens contribute significantly to the community and should have representation. Yet, this perspective is met with skepticism by many who argue that if anyone outside the citizenship framework is allowed to vote, it undermines the very foundation of democracy.
The dissenting judge, Jenny Rivera, contended that localities should have the authority to structure their voting regulations. However, the overwhelming majority of the court made it clear that state law must prevail.
This ruling sends a strong message that New York will not compromise on the principle that only citizens should vote, reinforcing a critical aspect of American democracy.
As concerns over election integrity continue to mount in a divided political landscape, this decision offers a significant step toward ensuring that every vote cast is genuinely representative of the citizens who earn that right through their allegiance to the United States.
Republicans across the state are hopeful that this win will bolster their efforts to uphold voter integrity and challenge similar laws that seek to expand voting rights to noncitizens in other jurisdictions.
Sources:
gothamist.com
courthousenews.com
trendingpoliticsnews.com
Latest News